How to respond to reviewer comments

Responding to reviewer comments means revising your manuscript and writing a point-by-point response letter that answers every comment, shows where you changed the paper and explains any change you did not make. A good response does four things:

An open binder with handwritten and printed pages on wood.
A binder of notes and a feedback slip for a revision.Photo: ha11ok / Pixabay
  1. 1

    Answers every comment

    Even the ones you decline.

  2. 2

    Shows the change

    Quote it, or give line numbers.

  3. 3

    Explains disagreement

    With evidence, politely.

  4. 4

    Stays short

    Clear and to the point.

Write your paper in Evernote. The AI Assistant builds your table, finds the exact line and plans the work.

Start your paper in Evernote

How to respond to reviewer comments in 6 steps

  1. 1

    Read the decision, then step back

    Assume the reviewers mean well, and ask what fundamental issues they want addressed.

  2. 2

    Make a plan and a list

    List every comment, mark which ones the editor says are required, and assign each to a co-author if you have them.

  3. 3

    Decide on new work

    If you need time for extra analyses or experiments, tell the editor early.

  4. 4

    Revise the manuscript

    Use track changes, or keep a list of line numbers for each change.

  5. 5

    Write the point-by-point letter

    Copy each comment, then your response and the change, with page or line numbers. Thank reviewers where the feedback helped.

  6. 6

    Explain anything you did not change

    Give your reasons and evidence. If reviewers disagree with each other, cite the editor's guidance.

Response letter example

A sample letter for a fictional manuscript on sleep and grades

1Dear Dr. Rivera, thank you for the opportunity to revise our manuscript. We thank both reviewers for their careful comments, which have improved the paper.

4Below, each comment is in italics, followed by our response and the changes. Line numbers refer to the revised manuscript with track changes.

5Reviewer 1, comment 1: "The authors should report how many participants dropped out." Response: Thank you. We now report that 12 of 100 students did not complete the study, and why (lines 112-115).

6Reviewer 1, comment 2: "Please add the night-before-test analysis to the main text." Response: We agree it is important, but because it showed no relation with scores, we kept it in the supplement and now summarize it in one sentence in the Results (line 188).

We hope the revised manuscript is now suitable for publication. Sincerely, the authors.

Hard cases and what to do

Guidance from PLOS on responding to peer review.

SituationWhat to do
You disagree with a commentDo not ignore it: explain why, with evidence
Two reviewers disagreeFollow the editor's guidance, and cite it in your response
The editor and a reviewer disagreeThe editor speaks for the journal's scope; cite the editor
A request is out of scopeYou can include the data in the letter and explain why it stays out of the paper
You need more timeTell the editor before the deadline

PLOS, "Responding to peer review".

Trusted by Millions Worldwide

4.4

2,100+ reviews on G2

4.4

8,200+ reviews on Capterra

4.4

73,000+ reviews on App Store

248M

Registered users

Reviewer response questions

What is a response to reviewers letter?

A letter submitted with your revised manuscript that lists each reviewer comment, your answer and the change you made.

Do I have to make every change a reviewer asks for?

No, but you must respond to every comment. If you decline, explain why, or reviewers may ask again in the next round.

How do I disagree with a reviewer politely?

Thank them, acknowledge the point, then give your reasons and evidence. Keep the tone factual.

Should I thank the reviewers?

Yes, briefly. If a comment was especially helpful, say so.

How long should the response letter be?

As short as possible while answering every point. Long explanations belong in the manuscript if they matter to readers.

What does major revision mean?

The editor will consider the paper again after substantial changes. It is not a rejection, but the revised paper may be reviewed again.

How to manage a revision with Evernote

Keep the decision letter, the manuscript and your response notes in one notebook. The AI Assistant helps you answer every comment and track each change.

  1. 1

    Table the comments.

    Ask the AI Assistant for a table of the reviewer comments with your response and the change. It reads your notes and adds the table to your response letter.

  2. 2

    Find a number.

    Ask for a number a reviewer requested, such as the dropout count. The Assistant answers with a link to the source note, and the matching words are highlighted on the PDF page.

  3. 3

    Plan the revision.

    Ask it to add a task for each revision step, with due dates before the deadline. You get a reminder for each one.

  • You can also annotate the decision letter PDF with each comment.
  • You can also search inside every PDF for the line a reviewer cites.
  • You can also ask the AI Assistant to check that every comment has a response.

Save your sources in one notebook

Save your articles and PDFs in one notebook, let the AI Assistant build the table you need, and get a task for each step.

Start for free