What is commentary in an essay?

Commentary is the part of an essay where you explain and interpret your evidence in your own words: what it means, why it matters and how it supports your thesis. Good commentary answers four questions:

An open book with passages marked in bright colors
A marked passage to explain in your commentary.Photo: BookBabe / Pixabay
  1. 1

    What does it mean?

    Put the evidence in your own words.

  2. 2

    Why did I pick it?

    What makes it significant.

  3. 3

    How does it prove it?

    The link to your thesis.

  4. 4

    So what?

    Its wider impact or context.

Plan yours in Evernote. The AI Assistant turns your notes and sources into an outline.

Plan your essay in Evernote

How to write commentary in 5 steps

  1. 1

    Start from your point

    Before the evidence, know what claim it supports. Rephrasing your thesis as a question keeps the commentary focused on answering it.

  2. 2

    Introduce the evidence

    Give context and the source, then the quote, fact or example.

  3. 3

    Explain what it means

    Interpret the evidence: what it says, and what is significant about it.

  4. 4

    Connect it to the thesis

    Say how and why the evidence supports your argument. This is the sentence that turns evidence into an argument.

  5. 5

    Check the balance

    Highlight every sentence of commentary in one color. If evidence outweighs commentary, add explanation.

Evidence and commentary, annotated

Body paragraph from an essay on school start times

2Evidence: In 2021, 84% of 12th graders told a CDC survey they slept less than 8 hours on an average school night.

3Commentary, meaning: That is not a few tired students; it is most of a senior class.

4Commentary, link to thesis: When a problem is that widespread, the cause is more likely the schedule everyone shares than the habits of individual students.

5Balance: one sentence of evidence, two of commentary.

Frameworks for evidence and commentary

Teachers use different names for the same idea: make a point, back it up, explain it.

FrameworkStands for
Quote sandwichContext, evidence, analysis
ACEAnswer, cite, explain
PIEPoint (topic sentence), illustration (evidence), explanation (analysis)
CERClaim, evidence, reasoning, mostly in science class

From the UC Davis Writing Center "Analysis quick guide" and the BSCS scientific explanation tool.

Free essay outline template

Fill in one line per part before you write a full sentence. Copy it, or save it to your Evernote account next to your sources.

Prompt: [what the assignment asks you to do, in your own words]

Introduction
Hook:
[a fact, question or short scene]
Context:
[what the reader needs to know]
Thesis:
[your claim] because [reason 1], [reason 2] and [reason 3].

Body 1
Topic sentence:
[reason 1]
Evidence:
[quote or fact] ([source])
Explanation:
[how it proves the thesis]

Body 2
Topic sentence:
[reason 2]
Evidence:
[quote or fact] ([source])
Explanation:
[how it proves the thesis]

Body 3
Topic sentence:
[reason 3, or the other side and your answer]
Evidence:
[quote or fact] ([source])
Explanation:
[how it proves the thesis]

Conclusion
[The thesis in new words.] [What the three reasons add up to.] [Why it matters.]

Trusted by Millions Worldwide

4.4

2,100+ reviews on G2

4.4

8,200+ reviews on Capterra

4.4

73,000+ reviews on App Store

248M

Registered users

Commentary questions

What is commentary in an essay?

Your explanation and interpretation of the evidence: what it means and how it supports your argument. The UC Davis Writing Center calls this analysis.

How much commentary should I write?

Enough to explain every piece of evidence. The UC Davis Writing Center suggests highlighting every sentence of analysis in one color to see whether you need more.

What is the difference between evidence and commentary?

Evidence is the quote, fact or example from a source. Commentary is what you say about it.

How do I start commentary?

With phrases that move from the source to your reading: "This shows that", "In other words", "This matters because".

Why is commentary important?

It is where your own thinking appears. On the AP English rubric, evidence and commentary together are worth 4 of the 6 points.

What questions help me write commentary?

Why did I choose this evidence? What is its significance? How does it support, or complicate, my argument? What is its impact in a wider context?

How to strengthen your commentary with Evernote

Plan each paragraph from an outline that pairs every piece of evidence with the point it supports.

  1. 1

    Outline from your notes.

    Ask the AI Assistant to build an outline for your commentary from the notes in that notebook. It writes each point and cites the note it came from.

  2. 2

    Plan it to the due date.

    Ask it to split the outline for your commentary into tasks before the due date, each with its own date.

  3. 3

    Check the length.

    Ask how many words your commentary has. It counts them and points to the part that needs more evidence.

  • You can also ask the AI Assistant to find every quote you saved about one point, across all your source notes.
  • You can also select a sentence and ask the AI Assistant to rephrase it, then keep only the wording that still sounds like you.

Keep your notes and outline in one place

Keep the prompt and every source in one notebook, let the AI Assistant outline and schedule the work, and write it in your own words.

Start for free