How to tell if a journal is peer reviewed

A journal is peer reviewed if its editor sends submitted articles to other experts in the field, who judge the research before it is accepted. You can confirm it in four places:

Two hands with a silver pen over printed pages on wood.
Checking a journal review policy against the printed page.Photo: WokinghamLibraries / Pixabay
  1. 1

    The journal website

    Look under author instructions or About.

  2. 2

    Ulrichsweb

    Peer-reviewed journals are marked "refereed".

  3. 3

    Library databases

    Look for a peer-reviewed tag or filter.

  4. 4

    The article type

    Editorials and book reviews are not reviewed.

Write your paper in Evernote. The AI Assistant builds your table, finds the exact line and plans the work.

Start your paper in Evernote

How to check if a journal is peer reviewed in 5 steps

  1. 1

    Find the journal's website

    Search for the journal title, not the article. Use the publisher's official page.

  2. 2

    Read the author instructions

    Look for "Information for authors", "Submit an article" or "About this journal". These pages describe the review process.

  3. 3

    Check Ulrichsweb

    Many libraries subscribe. Search the journal title: a refereed icon and a "Refereed: Yes" field mean it is peer reviewed.

  4. 4

    Use your library database

    Databases such as Academic Search Complete tag peer-reviewed publications, and most let you filter search results to peer-reviewed only.

  5. 5

    Check the type of article

    In a peer-reviewed journal, editorials, letters and book reviews are not peer reviewed in many cases. Make sure your source is a research or review article.

Peer review checklist

Run these checks on any journal before you cite it

1Journal website

  • Official publisher page foundNot a copy or a database page

2Author instructions

  • Review process describedUnder information for authors or About

3Ulrichsweb

  • Refereed: YesThrough your library's database list

4Library database

  • Peer-reviewed tag or filterOn the journal or the article record

5The article

  • A research or review articleNot an editorial, letter or book review
  • Has methods, results and referencesThe structure of reviewed research

If you cannot find evidence that a journal is peer reviewed and your assignment requires it, choose a different source.

Where to check, and what you will see

Use more than one check when a source matters.

WhereWhat to look for
Journal websiteA peer review policy under author instructions or About
UlrichswebRefereed icon, and the "Refereed" field set to Yes
Library searchA peer-reviewed icon or filter on the result
Print issueAuthor instructions and review policy inside the covers or near the end

Oregon State University Libraries, "Scholarly Articles: How can I tell?"; University of Texas at Dallas Libraries, "How to Determine if a Journal Is Peer-Reviewed"; University of Queensland Library, "Check if it's peer-reviewed".

Trusted by Millions Worldwide

4.4

2,100+ reviews on G2

4.4

8,200+ reviews on Capterra

4.4

73,000+ reviews on App Store

248M

Registered users

Peer review questions

What does peer reviewed mean?

The journal's editor sent the article to other researchers in the same field, who evaluated the quality of the research, the data and the conclusions before it was published.

Is peer reviewed the same as scholarly?

Not exactly. Most scholarly journals are peer reviewed, but not every one is. Check each journal.

What is a refereed journal?

Another name for a peer-reviewed journal. Ulrichsweb uses the word "refereed".

Can I tell from the article alone?

Only partly. A research structure with methods and references is a clue, but the journal's own review policy is the reliable check.

Are all articles in a peer-reviewed journal peer reviewed?

No. Editorials, letters, news and book reviews in the same journal are not peer reviewed in many cases.

Is Google Scholar only peer-reviewed work?

No. It searches articles, theses, books, abstracts and court opinions from many kinds of sites. Check the journal for each article you plan to cite.

How to check peer review with Evernote

Keep the journal page, the author guidelines and your checklist in one notebook. The AI Assistant helps you confirm the review policy from the sources you saved.

  1. 1

    Table the checks.

    Ask the AI Assistant for a table of the checks and where to look for each. It reads your notes and adds the table to your checklist.

  2. 2

    Find the review statement.

    Ask where the journal says its articles are peer reviewed. The Assistant answers with a link to the guidelines, and the matching words are highlighted on the PDF page.

  3. 3

    Plan the checks.

    Ask it to add a task for each check, with due dates before your assignment. You get a reminder for each one.

  • You can also clip the journal author instructions with the Web Clipper.
  • You can also search inside every PDF for the word refereed.
  • You can also ask the AI Assistant to summarize the review policy in one sentence.

Save your sources in one notebook

Save your articles and PDFs in one notebook, let the AI Assistant build the table you need, and get a task for each step.

Start for free